THE TIMES
Don’t let your child be master of the
universe
Barbara McMahon
Published at 12:01AM, June 21 2014
At a children’s birthday party,
seven-year-old Suzie was upset because she had been promised chocolate chip ice
cream but got cookie dough ice cream instead. She threw a tantrum that made
Violet-Elizabeth Bott, the lisping character in the Just
William books who “thscreamed” until she was “thick”, seem positively
reasonable. Dr Robin Berman, a psychiatrist and a mother of three, was among
the parents at the party rooting for Suzie’s mother to calmly intervene.
Instead, the agitated mother tried to placate her child, negotiate with her and
finally started picking out the bits of cookie dough and putting them in her
own mouth. “She totally capitulated, rushing in to fix her daughter’s
unhappiness,” Berman says. “We were all blown away by it and then I realised that this stuff was going on everywhere I looked.”
We are a well-intentioned generation that
has gone awry, asserts the American therapist in her book Hate Me Now, Thank Me Later,
How to Raise Your Child with Love and Limits. “We are pleaser parents who are being
pushed around by our own children and too many little inmates are running the
show. Over the past few decades, the parental power structure central to the
family unit has gone off-kilter. Parents who vowed never to hit their kids as they
had been hit and not to rule the household with an iron fist have gone too far
the other way.
“Children used to be seen and not heard and
now they are the centre of the universe,” Berman says. Instead of becoming
happier, however, children are growing angrier and more fragile. Psychiatrists
are seeing an increase in anxiety disorders, drug dependence and
depression
in children, adolescents and young adults. “Overparenting
and overprotection have truly backfired,” she says. “Kids today are not better
off, they’re more dependent, more risk averse, more entitled and less
resilient. This wasn’t what we were aiming for.”
According to Berman, we need to steady the
parenting pendulum in a new middle, keeping some of our parents’ methods,
learning from recent parenting trends and reflecting on what no longer serves
us. In the book she lists some of the ways that parents have got it wrong. We
indulge our children’s demands and tantrums. We enter into endless negotiations
about everything from bedtime to leaving the park. We allow our kids to hit us.
We “good-job” them to death. We don’t let them fail in
case it hurts their self esteem. In short, we have handed children too much
power.
“Children with too much power often become
anxious because they feel like they have to control their environment and they
really don’t know how,” Berman says. “When we rush to fix our children’s
disappointments and negative feelings, we unintentionally cripple them. Our
task as parents is to help our children self-soothe, to build up their
emotional immune systems so that they can fight the big battles when they come
along.”
Berman has extensive experience in helping
both parents and children navigate complicated family dynamics. An associate
professor of psychiatry at the University of California, Los Angeles, she also
runs her own private practice and teaches Reflective Parenting, developed from
the work of the psychoanalyst Peter Fonagy at the Tavistock Clinic in London. “Reflective parenting is really
a psychological space where parents can come in and talk about issues and
reflect on them so they can do it differently next time,” Berman says.
Even though some of this well-meaning but
misguided parental behaviour is entrenched, it is
never too late to turns things around, Berman says. Even stroppy teenagers will
respect a parent who calls the shots consistently and calmly. ”You’ll be amazed
how quickly children flourish when they are helped to manage their emotions and
allowed to master some things by themselves,” she says.
With a reputation as a parenting guru, she
thinks the reason why her wise and instructive book is rushing up the
bestseller lists in the United States is because parents recognise
that things are out of balance. “Being our kids’ friends and raising our kids
around 20,000 activities is not right, and we know that intuitively, and we’re
being given permission to slow down. I’ve had parents coming up to me in tears
and thanking me,” she says.
The actress Reese Witherspoon, who has
three children, has endorsed Berman’s book, calling it a “must-read guide” that
should be given to every new parent. “Our children went to pre-school together
and she’s a very sensible mother who does a great job of holding the line when
it comes to discipline,” says the therapist.
Berman wrote the book from her own
experience as a mother, a psychiatrist and a parenting group leader — and from
speaking to teachers, coaches, paediatricians,
therapists, parents and children to gather their collective insights. The
essential message of Hate
Me Now, Thank Me Later
is that children need limits more than they need indulgences and
parents need to be more comfortable setting boundaries.
One of the most important things that
parents can do is to stop over-protecting their children. Berman points out in
the book that if a mother hen tried to crack the eggshell to help her baby out,
the chick would die. “Our hovering and over-involvement are preventing our kids
from fully hatching,” she says. “Parents are trying to take the sharp edges out
of their kids’ lives but part of life is negotiating the edge. When we remove
it, we deprive children of the opportunity to practice managing and assessing
risk. If you treat children as fragile, they will stay fragile for life.”
She says parents used to sit on the park
bench and watch their children play. Now they are at the bottom of the climbing
frame, instructing their children how to climb, or hanging on to the end of
their children’s bikes so they don’t fall and scrape their knees. We are
teaching children that they need us in order to succeed. When parents
over-function, children under-function, she says.
Dependency also breeds resentment among
parents and children. Children act out because lack of empowerment frustrates
them, while parents become exhausted and resentful when they do everything 24/7
for their children. A good parent works himself or herself out of a job, Berman
points out. The goal should be to let our children become frustrated and work some
things out for themselves because this increases their “psychological padding”.
We should also back away from thinking that
we can control our children’s future by obsessing over their sporting achievements
and academic accomplishments.
Berman compares this to being the
white-knuckled passenger on an aircraft. In the same way that gripping our
seats and pushing imaginary brakes will not make an aircraft land safely, many children
with good marks will not get into the university of their
choice or yours or become professional sports people.
Too much pressure and stress is not good
for growing children. “A little stress can boost performance but chronic, daily
stress can actually shrink the hippocampus, where memory resides. It can
increase headaches, cause ulcers, decrease immune
function and trigger autoimmune disease. Stress also worsens all psychiatric
illnesses,” she explains.
Setting high standards for a child is great
but obsessing over performance increases anxiety. “You see these dads screaming
from the sidelines and the kid doesn’t even know which direction to face, and
if that father just took the kid into the garden and dug in the mud or climbed
a tree or threw a ball, that would give them a bond they’re not going to get in
soccer when a kid is four years old and his dad’s screaming ‘The other way! Go!
Win! Shoot!’ ” she says.
Parents should let go of fear and anxiety.
“It’s like a race and we’re trying to get ahead and give our children a leg-up.
I think many parents are deluded because in their hearts they think they are
doing the best thing for their children and it’s just a misunderstanding. Doing
the best for your children is, a lot of times, allowing them to do for
themselves.”
Good parenting will make you periodically
unpopular, Berman warns, but your children will appreciate you in the future
when they become psychologically stable and resilient adults.
Take your lead from great world leaders,
she advises. “Look how kind history is to world leaders who take a firm stand
on doing what is right, even though it might mean being unpopular at the time,”
she adds. “Free yourself from fears of being the bad guy.”
How to take back control, by Dr Robin Berman
Set
clear limits
Using angry words or punishment may control
behaviour in the short term but intimidation chips
away at the foundation of a child’s self-esteem and paves the way for defences to be built. The child’s real self goes
underground. Discipline done right fosters self-esteem, whereas harsh or
shaming discipline erodes self-esteem. In fact, discipline means “to teach”.
Set clear limits and enforce them with love. Take a parental time-out and put
some space between what’s annoying you and your response. Have understanding of
your child’s struggle. Let him or her know that their feelings are valid, even empathised with, but that the limit remains. Having a
boundary, and a firm consequence when the child crosses the line, creates
accountability. It empowers children to police their own sense of right and wrong.
Enforce
limits consistently
Following through some times and not others
spells disaster. In psychiatry this is called variable reinforcement, which
means that a response is reinforced in an unpredictable manner. If your child
feels that your threats are empty and that every once in a while you might
follow through, it will be hard to discipline effectively. Kids learn best with
consistent follow-through. They learn to trust that you do what you say and say
what you mean. If you don’t follow through, you can seem unreliable in your
child’s eyes. A mother I admire has no tolerance for whining and uses phrases
with her children such as: “I can’t hear you when you speak that way.”
Consistent reinforcement has extinguished whining in her home.
Reverse
negotiate
The more children argue, the less they get.
It works like a charm. For example: Parent: Bedtime is at eight. Child: I want
to stay up till eight-thirty. Parent: No, it’s eight. Child: I want to stay up
later. Parent: Now bedtime is seven-forty-five. Child: Fine, I’ll take eight. Parent:
Now bedtime is at seven-thirty. You must stick to this revised bedtime.
Too
much information
Another pendulum swing in today’s parenting
culture is excessive talk and excessive explanations. We’ve gone from: “No,
because I said so” to reasoning through every issue till we’re blue in the
face. Make it short and sweet. Give them bite-size pieces that are easily digestible.
A parent’s excessive verbiage can get tuned out – or worse, become baggage. Children’s
brains are developing daily. Don’t fill them with unnecessary information,
white noise or, worse, our own anxieties.
Too
many choices
It is burdensome and stressful for a child
to have to make too many daily choices. I watched in shock as a mum asked her
five-year-old daughter: “Do you think Mummy should take the new job at the bank
or keep her old one?” Kids don’t have the brain capacity for those big decisions.
Empowering kids to make choices has to be age appropriate. “Do you want chicken
or pasta?” is fine for a five-year-old but asking her to weigh in on a job is
absurd. Don’t invert the roles. Your child is not your friend, your masseuse or
your confidant.
False
praise
The -est
words can be harmful on many levels. The “you are the fastest/smartest” type of
feedback leaves kids no incentive for growth and undermines development.
Constant praise fosters a neediness for more praise
and creates a self-conscious child. The excessively praised child may be more
prone to exaggerate accomplishments or, on the flip side, be overly
self-critical. Praise works best when it is specific and when you praise the
effort rather than the outcome. Teach kids that trying hard matters.
Loosen
the reins
Overprotection blocks children’s emerging
independence. If you hold on to the back of their bike too long or coach them
with flash cards you are sending the message that they’re not good enough do
these things by themselves. That is the opposite of self-esteem. Every child need
to learn how to lose and to be a good sport, and most of all to tolerate
frustration. It seems counterintuitive but your goal should be to let your
child get frustrated. It literally makes them more resilient.
Go
easy on yourself
Parenting is a dynamic under stressful,
always-juggling, short-on-time, short-on-sleep conditions. There is a high
degree of human error. Luckily for us, kids are very forgiving. And human error
creates a wonderful opportunity for real closeness. Where there is rupture,
follow it with repair. Own your mistake. Apology will not undermine your authority.
It actually strengthens your credibility as a trustworthy leader.
It’s
never too late
Out of the best intentions we have made
children vulnerable to stress but it is amazing how quickly you can turn things
around by being a benevolent leader.
Adapted from Hate Me Now, Thank Me Later: How to
Raise Your Child With Love and Limits by
Dr Robin Berman. HarperCollins, £12.99